Posted by: mutantpoodle | March 10, 2010

About the Filibuster

I’m just gonna steal from Ezra Klein, who spoke with political scientist Sarah Binder, who literally wrote the book on the filibuster. Turns out the filibuster isn’t a precious constitutional gem, revered by the founders. It’s actually a mistake:

“We all know the Constitution says the House and Senate can make their own rules,” explains Binder. “So in 1789, each chamber draws up their own set of rules. And both sets of rules have a previous question motion, which is the motion that the House uses to cut off debate by majority vote.”

Quick interlude here, because it confused me: The “previous question motion” refers to the motion asking whether the body should move to a vote. It’s called “previous question” because the language is generally something along the lines of “shall we now move to the main question?” In other words, the motion shuts down the previous question — hence the name. Alright. Back to Binder.

“In 1805, Aaron Burr has just killed Alexander Hamilton. He comes back to the Senate and gives his farewell address. Burr basically says that you are a great body. You are conscientious and wise, you do not give in to the whims of passion. But your rules are a mess. And he goes through the rulebook pointing out duplicates and things that are unclear.”

“Among his suggestions was to drop the previous question motion. And they pretty much just take Burr’s advice. And once it’s gone, it takes some time for leaders to realize that they can’t cut off debate anymore. But the striking part to me was that we say the Senate developed the filibuster to protect minorities and the right to debate. That’s hogwash! It’s a mistake. Believe me, I would’ve loved to find the smoking gun where the Senate decides to create a deliberative body. But it takes years before anyone figures out that the filibuster has just been created.”

And once they do figure it out, of course, they could never rid themselves of it because the minority never had an interest in letting go of their advantage.



  1. This is why we need historians… Binder is a good one!

  2. Thanks for the facts. Very important stuff.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: